Answer by Dharmaraj for Triage needs to be fixed urgently, and users need to...
I'm not sure if it's late to respond here.But the confusion that 'Requires editing' creates is who is supposed to edit the post. It states, anyone on the site should be able to edit the question to...
View ArticleClik here to view.
Answer by Noah Broyles for Triage needs to be fixed urgently, and users need...
I reached 500 rep yesterday and was given the Review Queue privilege. I was also banned from the Review Queue for use of the deadly Requires Editing button in Triage the same day. Something is Wrong!I...
View ArticleClik here to view.
Answer by Nakx for Triage needs to be fixed urgently, and users need to be...
I got recently banned for a long period of time and thought this was the first time, here is why:The icon that mentions you are banned looks like you are notified there is a need to help the review...
View ArticleClik here to view.
Answer by Glorfindel for Triage needs to be fixed urgently, and users need to...
Given this announcement on Meta Stack Exchange they're going to make serious work on some of the points:2. Retain a link in the top bar review queue menu for users in review suspensionIn the event of a...
View ArticleAnswer by Jerie Wang for Triage needs to be fixed urgently, and users need to...
I have reviewed a few hundred triages over the past years and it's the first time that I got review banned. I see why this happened and I will continue review posts after the ban ends. However, here...
View ArticleAnswer by Z4-tier for Triage needs to be fixed urgently, and users need to be...
A lot of posts are focusing on the Triage queue, but that is really only one piece of the larger problem. The real issue here is that posts are getting stuck in H&I and there is no "by design"...
View ArticleAnswer by Gangula for Triage needs to be fixed urgently, and users need to be...
I have just been review banned and quite frankly I felt a little dispirited. After taking some time to read all the MetaSO posts, questions and answers (like this) related to Triage, I agree with why...
View ArticleAnswer by rtx13 for Triage needs to be fixed urgently, and users need to be...
Interim Solution ProposalI'd like to propose an interim solution that should require relatively little effort but result in reduced incorrect triage. I haven't read all of the other answers in this and...
View ArticleAnswer by apokryfos for Triage needs to be fixed urgently, and users need to...
There's something that is really bothering me about this post so I feel like I must post this. You have stated the numbers: 118 bans from failing review audits and 2118 manually banned. You also...
View ArticleAnswer by Chuck Adams for Triage needs to be fixed urgently, and users need...
Funny, I always thought I'd get review-banned for clicking "Unsalvagable" instead of "Needs Editing". Turns out it was the other vague and subjective distinction that I should have chosen all this...
View ArticleAnswer by MBorg for Triage needs to be fixed urgently, and users need to be...
Adding the 'Edit' option for Triage that is normally accessible when viewing questions and answers, including from review 'First Posts' and 'Late Answers,' I think could help alleviate the problem.As...
View ArticleAnswer by omnidan for Triage needs to be fixed urgently, and users need to be...
I think one of the main issues here is that people are encouraged to review/triage without giving them a good enough introduction on how to do it properly.My storyI personally wanted to try out the...
View ArticleAnswer by Yaakov Ellis for Triage needs to be fixed urgently, and users need...
Thanks everyone for your suggestions and feedback. We plan on addressing this issue as part of our upcoming review queue overhaul project, and will be taking everything written here into...
View ArticleAnswer by jeb for Triage needs to be fixed urgently, and users need to be...
Triage bans are a good way to offend users.Sometimes, I worked on the close or reopen queues.Today, I used the triage queue the first time.And I got banned for clicking at the Requires Editing...
View ArticleAnswer by gnat for Triage needs to be fixed urgently, and users need to be...
I recently took time to study triage items and as far as I could tell, the system can (or rather, should) be tweaked (with reasonably small development effort) to help inexperienced reviewers do more...
View ArticleAnswer by Rusty Robot for Triage needs to be fixed urgently, and users need...
As someone who is currently banned from reviewing because of this exact issue I thought I would give my reasoning and thoughts on a solution.My Experience as a Reviewer Who Got BannedTriage question It...
View ArticleAnswer by RET for Triage needs to be fixed urgently, and users need to be...
I would assert that the problem here is that the options do not reflect all possibilities. Describing a post that requires additional information from the asker as 'Unsalvageable' is plainly incorrect....
View ArticleAnswer by bad_coder for Triage needs to be fixed urgently, and users need to...
I have to apply manual bans and pray hard that the users chance upon the review ban message, WHICH IS NOT ALREADY APPARENT AND THEY GO ON TO DO THE SAME THING AGAIN AND AGAIN.I was given 1 manual ban...
View ArticleClik here to view.
Answer by Haem for Triage needs to be fixed urgently, and users need to be...
Adding written instructions to guide the people that don't read written instructions won't work. So, here's a suggestion for changing the "Requires editing" button's functionality I have been...
View ArticleAnswer by James Coyle for Triage needs to be fixed urgently, and users need...
This is probably controversial but I would like to see Triage and Low Quality Posts merged and have Help and Improvement, First Posts, and Late Answers removed/merged as well.Triage and Low Quality...
View ArticleAnswer by Catija for Triage needs to be fixed urgently, and users need to be...
There's a lot of focus on the "requires editing" option. I think there's some adjustment that we could make there to the description but if we're looking at a quick fix while we're considering other...
View ArticleAnswer by user10957435 for Triage needs to be fixed urgently, and users need...
EDIT: I see you've actually taken my suggestion and added to your list (sort of. IMO, you've made it even better). My only problem is it makes this post kind of useless ;). That's certainly a problem I...
View ArticleAnswer by jpmc26 for Triage needs to be fixed urgently, and users need to be...
I have a hard time believing that implementing a required tutorial would be any less work than adding a reason for Requires Editing that auto-generates a comment. (As I proposed previously.)...
View ArticleAnswer by Igor F. for Triage needs to be fixed urgently, and users need to be...
Triage is a flawed concept in this context. In the real world, triage is used to quickly classify subjects and leave their treatment (if required) to someone dedicated to that specific purpose. But,...
View ArticleClik here to view.
Answer by Mukyuu for Triage needs to be fixed urgently, and users need to be...
Can we just remove the Requires Editing button in Triage in the meanwhile?It's so confusing and more often than not it's not useful.Also in Help & Improvement more often than not I want to downvote...
View ArticleAnswer by Laurel for Triage needs to be fixed urgently, and users need to be...
Getting a ban is a meh way to notify the user about the rules: it doesn’t leave a good impression, some damage has already been done, and it requires moderator time. Earlier is better. Clicking...
View ArticleAnswer by ouflak for Triage needs to be fixed urgently, and users need to be...
I burned out reviewing on Triage. It was like trying to review the Wild Wild West. No sense of direction, anything goes (Or does it? Who knows?). I believe that if I had had a strong clear sense of...
View ArticleTriage needs to be fixed urgently, and users need to be notified upon...
PrologueSince late 2019, I have been investigating why posts are ending up in the Help & Improvement (H&I) review queue when it should have been closed in Triage. Unfortunately, due to the poor...
View Article
